We began hearing whispers that something was brewing behind the scenes with these two as early as August 2008. To spare Hef's reputation, Criss, 41, and Holly, 29, waited patiently until she was completely moved out of the Playboy Mansion before publicly acknowledging that they were a couple.
While the final decision to end things was said to be mutual, "It was a conflict of schedules. She felt she couldn't devote 100 percent of her time in Vegas and his career at the expense of her career and her goals," a source told E! News. Why not? She happily ditched her career aspirations to be with Hef for seven long years!
Photo Credit: Ethan Miller/Getty Images.